0263 | Invasion Of The Body Snatchers

Famously passed over by indifferent critics on its release in 1956, Don Siegel’s enjoyable sci-fi horror Invasion Of The Body Snatchers has since been re-appraised as a subversive work that addresses – depending on whose opinion you read – the spread of Communism across the United States, the dangers of McCarthyism, the rise in post-war small town homogenisation or even concerns over the sudden ubiquity of television sets. There is certainly a degree of evidence in support of each of these allegorical readings, and even though the ironically-named leading man Kevin McCarthy felt that any political statements were unintentional, Siegel later confirmed ‘the … reference to Senator McCarthy and totalitarianism was inescapable, but I tried not to emphasize it because I feel that motion pictures are primarily to entertain, and I did not want to preach’. The director’s words clearly lend more weight to the idea of a McCarthyism subtext, but the other theories shouldn’t be dismissed as irrelevant.

Siegel’s film, routinely referred to today as one of the great paranoia-driven 1950s sci-fi movies, takes place almost entirely in flashback and is set within the confines of the fictional Santa Mira: the kind of reasonably affluent, predominantly white Californian town where everybody on Main Street knows each other (and also knows each other’s business). However the film opens somewhere else, with a ‘present day’ scene that introduces Dr. Miles Bennell (McCarthy), a seemingly crazy individual who has been detained in a hospital.

Following this intriguing beginning Siegel and screenwriter Daniel Mainwaring (adapting Jack Finney’s pulp novel The Body Snatchers) drip-feed details that explain why the doctor is so animated and insistent. We go back in time and see him as he arrives in Santa Mira after a short time away. Oddly, several members of the community reported feeling unwell while Bennell was out of town, but they have all subsequently retracted their statements and are claiming to feel fine. Other residents are apparently suffering from the Capgras delusion, and are convinced that close relatives have been replaced by identical imposters.

Though his film is only 80 minutes long Siegel refuses to cut to the chase, and instead slowly adds layer after layer of increasing weirdness, following Bennell and love interest Becky Driscoll (Dana Wynter) – another character returning to the town having gone through a divorce elsewhere – as they come into contact with various oddly-behaving townsfolk. When the otherworldly threat behind all the strange events in Santa Mira is first revealed there’s more than a whiff of Frankenstein’s monster as a featureless being lies immobile on a billiard table: this creature is an example of a ‘body snatching’ alien lifeform that hatches from seed pods and takes on the features and identity of whatever human happens to be sleeping nearby, except for their emotions. The focus hereafter, as Bennell and Driscoll realise the extent of the invasion and the speed that it is spreading, is on the pods: a much simpler and cheaper solution for a budget-conscious effects department, and the most obvious link to the ‘spread of television’ theory mentioned above.

The real tension in Invasion Of The Body Snatchers comes from a middle act where it is often unclear which residents of the town are still human and which residents have been ‘duplicated’ by the alien race; there’s little reliance on special effects, and in using the façade of apparent normality to mask an evil force, the influence of the story and Siegel can be seen in the later work of a range of directors, from Wes Craven to David Lynch. The basic idea here has been recycled repeatedly, most obviously in the equally-gripping 1978 remake starring Donald Sutherland, but also in films like The Faculty and The World’s End, while Abel Ferrara (Body Snatchers) and Oliver Hirschbiegel (The Invasion) have also adapted the source novel; on TV the idea has been used in shows like V and the more recent version of Battlestar Galactica. Understandably it feels a little tired today, but one can only imagine how it felt to American audiences during the 1950s.

There are a couple of twists as typically reliable figures of small-town society, such as the cops, are revealed to be duplicitous aliens. One excellent scene suddenly exposes the true extent of the problem, as Bennell watches an early morning gathering of the majority of the town’s ‘fake’ residents, and realises the pods are being distributed outside of Santa Mira. By this point the lead characters, fuelled by paranoia, a lack of sleep and amphetamines, are on the run. The mania builds until we flash forward to Bennell urgently ranting in the hospital, his earlier craziness now perfectly understandable. It’s here that, disappointingly, a chance for a sucker punch finale is missed: originally the film was to end on a flat, pessimistic note, but executives at Allied Artists insisted on an optimistic epilogue, against the wishes of Siegel and producer Walter Wanger. Eventually the pair conceded, and in truth the ending doesn’t spoil the movie, as the fate of mankind is precariously left hanging in the balance.

Invasion Of The Body Snatchers holds up well today, even though its horror is now considered tame enough for a PG rating. It’s a simple, compact film, but its thrills are numerous and its multi-layered story has helped to ensure longevity. Siegel went on to make bigger (and arguably better) movies with Clint Eastwood in the 1970s, but this earlier foray into sci-fi is one of his best achievements, an enjoyably paranoid romp that largely steers clear of the camp silliness prevalent elsewhere during the 1950s.

Directed by: Don Siegel.
Written by: Daniel Mainwairing. Based on The Body Snatchers by Jack Finney.
Starring: Kevin McCarthy, Dana Wynter, Larry Gates, King Donovan, Carolyn Jones.
Cinematography: Ellsworth Fredericks.
Editing: Robert S. Eisen.
Music: Carmen Dragon.
Certificate: PG.
Running Time: 80 minutes.
Year: 1956.
Rating: 7.7

Comments 12

  1. ruth April 9, 2015

    Good thing you said this is considered tame by today’s standards. Maybe I’ll check it out though generally I’m not a big fan of sci-fi horror. I’ve only seen a few, like The Fly, which was terrifying indeed.

    • Stu April 10, 2015

      Yeah this isn’t too bad Ruth. I just don’t think they had the budget or the technology or the capacity to show anything too gruesome back then, so it’s really on a par with most other 50s sci-fi. No great shocks, more of a mood piece if you know what I mean?

        • Stu April 10, 2015

          Haha no, nor mine. You’re more likely to see Andy Townsend in my wheelhouse than Joe DiMaggio.

        • Todd Benefiel May 13, 2015

          Wheelhouse: an area where a baseball is pitched that’s the prime spot for the batter to hit; the zone (about waist high) where he has the most bat power and best opportunity to make solid contact. Just thought I’d clarify. (And by the way, as opposed to those two sporting MEN you mentioned, I think I’d rather have Ann Sheridan in my wheelhouse).

  2. Todd Benefiel May 13, 2015

    Hey Stu! One of my favorite sci-fi films of the 1950s…and the book was a pretty good read, too. I really liked how Siegel and Mainwaring moved the story along slowly, and built suspense a step at a time. And I loved the billiard table moment, one of many scenes that had some truly great low-key creepage. I never saw the 1978 version…is it worth a look?

    • Stu May 13, 2015

      I liked that too Todd. They hold things back for a good thirty minutes or so and let the tension build, which is something I prefer (I just watched Pacific Rim and they bring the monsters in during the first minute or so, by way of comparison). The ’78 version is actually pretty good; I saw it a long time ago so my memory of it isn’t great but there are lots of creepy shots of nature and they tap into the same kind of paranoia as the original. Plus it has Donald Sutherland and Dr Spock in it!

Get in touch...

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s