0291 | The Breakfast Club

the-breakfast-club-molly-ringwald-emilio-estevezFerris Bueller’s Day Off is better than anything else the late John Hughes made, in my opinion, but the rest of his output as writer and/or director is peppered with films that are worth the occasional repeat viewing. Take The Breakfast Club for example: a typical mid-1980s teen dramedy dated by its clothes, haircuts, Simple Minds theme song and reliance on once-popular Brat Pack actors, it actually holds up fairly well today because of the simplicity of its conceit, and also thanks to the winning ensemble performance of its mainly young cast.

In case your memory needs jogging, it’s Saturday morning in Michigan and we’re watching an extended detention: five teenagers are thrown together in the same room because of unseen prior indiscretions, while Paul Gleason’s grumpy teacher oversees the punishment. Judd Nelson is the mouthy rebel Bender, who demands most of your attention as he locks horns with Emilio Estevez’s jock Andrew, while Molly Ringwald’s pristine ‘princess’ Claire is usually on the receiving end of Bender’s insults. Anthony Michael Hall’s geeky ‘brain’ Brian watches from the sidelines and Ally Sheedy’s oddball recluse Allison sits at the back eating cereal sandwiches.

These kids are well aware of their supposed differences and each has a sense of where they fit, or where they are supposed to fit, into the various high school cliques and pecking orders. Hughes concentrates on their mutual mistrust at first, before the characters gradually open up to one another and realise collectively that they do in fact have plenty in common: each is unhappy at home because of parental issues that vary in terms of severity, while their individual personas mask shared pressures and insecurities. Their opinions of each other gradually change over the course of the eight hour detention, while the time is also filled with crying, dancing, makeovers, pot smoking and general teen kerrrrrazy-ness.

Hughes’s characters are memorable, and even though actors like John Cusack, Nicolas Cage and Rick Moranis were overlooked, each part was cast successfully. Amusingly three of those involved – Nelson, Estevez and Sheedy – played university students in St. Elmo’s Fire, the other most famous Brat Pack movie, which was released in the same year; as such it’s a stretch to accept one or two of them as being young enough to be attending high school, though it certainly isn’t an insurmountable problem. Nelson and Sheedy stand out, probably because they get to play the most interesting characters, while Gleason’s performance as the grumpy teacher is another to be enjoyed. His assistant principal Vernon represents the writer’s clear misgivings about the ability of adults to relate to teenagers: he is deeply unhappy because of his job, and he takes it out on the younger characters as a result, failing to identify with or understand them.

The writer-director’s script is packed with believable dialogue, and his historical importance in terms of changing the way (white American) teens were portrayed by Hollywood should not be understated: prior to Sixteen Candles, Hughes’s 1984 debut as director, teenagers were generally being portrayed as sex-mad idiots or mindless fodder for horror villains. The Michigan native, along with Cameron Crowe (who wrote the earlier script for Amy Heckerling’s Fast Times At Ridgemont High) gave them a new, modern voice and The Breakfast Club, arguably more than any other film, was successful in bringing typical concerns to the big screen. It has arguably become a little overrated in the years since its release but it still makes for a fine, low-key counterpoint to the more energetic teen-centric films of the same year (The Goonies, Back To The Future), while the oft-seen ‘relationships between characters locked in a room gradually change’ plot (12 Angry Men, Reservoir Dogs, Rope, Tape, etc.) is given a fresh spin.

Directed by: John Hughes.
Written by: John Hughes.
Starring: Judd Nelson, Molly Ringwald, Emilio Estevez, Ally Sheedy, Anthony Michael Hall, Paul Gleason.
Cinematography: Thomas Del Ruth.
Editing: Dede Allen.
Music: Keith Forsey, Various.
Certificate: 15.
Running Time: 97 minutes.
Year: 1985.
Rating: 7.2.

Comments 30

    • Stu May 28, 2015

      Thanks…I often make that distinction too! I remember reading your thoughts on this during your John Hughes blogathon. I think this is a very good one and I always enjoy watching Pretty In Pink and Planes, Trains and Automobiles too. Haven’t seen Weird Science in YEARS though!

    • Stu May 28, 2015

      Hi Khalid. I’d go along with that: it’s not a straightforward comedy like those other films (I used the phrase ‘dramedy’ in the review to signal that it’s somewhere in between drama and comedy). There is some serious stuff in The Breakfast Club but also plenty of face-pulling, silly dancing and sharp insults, etc.

  1. Wendell May 28, 2015

    I actually view things a little differently. I think Ferris is the most fun Hughes flick, but this is his best. It takes the teens from being merely types to being actual people right before our eyes. You’re right about Hughes’ place in film history. What he did for (American white) teens in cinema is enormous. Nearly every teen movie made after this, Ferris, Fast Times, and Porky’s (maintaining the sex-mad idiot angle) owes there existence to one or more of these four. Great review.

    • Stu May 28, 2015

      Well said! The likes of Judd Apatow have even gone on record acknowledging the debt to Hughes in particular. We’ll have to agree to disagree on which film is his best!

        • Stu May 29, 2015

          I know the feeling! Every time I read a book about film or go on the internet or pick up a paper I end up adding stuff to a never-ending list! Ah well…it’ll be fun going through it all.

        • Jordan Dodd May 29, 2015

          Ha! Totally, my watchlist has over 100 titles on it… and that isn’t including new stuff just coming out! I agree though, its fun going through them all, even if it takes forever as the list always grows 😉

    • Stu May 29, 2015

      Gleason is one of those faces that is so familiar from 80s TV. I didn’t realise he was in Die Hard…it is so long since I sat down and watched that film!

      • Keith May 29, 2015

        Oh yes. He plays a character with the same loud, mean, and I’m noxious demeanor. He’s the police captain who comes and takes charge of the scene. Dwayne T Robinson. He is fantastic.

    • Stu May 31, 2015

      Haha she was always my favourite. I’m going to watch St Elmo’s Fire in the next day or two…Lovefilm sent me that and The Breakfast Club back to back.

  2. Tom July 12, 2015

    I think the further and further from The Breakfast Club’s release date we get the film is the beneficiary of a lot of hype because these teens perpetually represent high school archetypes. The jock, the bully, the nerd, the prissy girl, and the outcast essentially peg every corner of the communal student body, so each generation who ends up seeing this film is able to identify easily with the portrayals. I think it’s afforded Hughes’ film a lot of hype and while I can see that maybe it has earned maybe more than it should (it is a ridiculously low-key film, after all) I think my biggest love of it stems from the fact that it is such a universal experience. Being a teen. Being at odds with your parents (even if your relationship with your own is nowhere near as tumultuous as these poor kids’). Being stuck doing something you don’t want to do. That to me is the genius of this film.

    • Stu July 13, 2015

      Yeah, I like this film a lot, but because it has struck chord with some I’d agree that it seems to be over-celebrated. There are plenty of high school movies that I think are as good (or better) but this one seems to be the one that gets mentioned first/most.

Get in touch...

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s