0373 | The Martian

martian-sitsOnce you have accepted the premise that NASA has successfully landed astronauts on Mars in the not-too-distant future, perhaps the most surprising thing about Ridley Scott’s The Martian is the upbeat tone of this castaway tale: Matt Damon’s stranded astro-botanist Mark Watney spends much of the movie cracking wise as he records video diaries and explains exactly what he’s doing in order to survive on the red planet, and there’s very little exploration of the post-traumatic stress, misery and doubt that Watney and the crew members who abandoned him would surely experience in such a situation. Perhaps retaining a sense of humour in the face of extreme adversity is the only way to survive on Mars, completely alone, without going insane. The frothy, light touch here certainly makes for an interesting comparison with Gravity or last year’s autumn sci-fi epic Interstellar, a bombastic outer space movie that took itself way too seriously (though there were occasional light-hearted moments involving that particular film’s robot). And what’s this? A disco soundtrack? Gloria Gaynor was one of the last acts I was expecting to hear.

At the start of the film we find Watney and his crew conducting experiments on the planet’s surface. There are early signs that Scott has opted for a bloated cast packed with familiar faces as Watney jokes with Jessica Chastain’s commander Lewis and Michael Peña’s astronaut Martinez; the crew is completed by characters played by Kate Mara, Sebastian Stan and Aksel Hennie, all three up-and-coming stars. Soon enough an extreme dust storm threatens their collective safety and forces the intrepid astronauts to leave for Earth, but an the-martian-jessica-chastainaccident occurs, leading them to believe that Watney is dead, and they depart without him. But no! Our Mark manages to keep oxygen in his ripped space suit thanks to some implausible nonsense about shrapnel blocking the hole, and soon enough we’re following Watney’s attempts to grow potatoes out of his own faeces and establish communication links with NASA, which is apparently headed up by just four people (Jeff Daniels, Chiwetel Ejiofor, Sean Bean, Kristen Wiig). This small band of executives and spin doctors back on Earth plot rescue missions with Californian scientists (Benedict Wong and Donald Glover both make the most of their minor roles) and contact Watney’s old crew members. He’s alive! There’s hope! Let’s go get our boy! And so on and so forth.

You’re not supposed to over-think The Martian, which is fine, but the film simply fails to get to grips with the mental state of Damon’s character, and instead unquestionably embraces the triumph of the human spirit and the notion of good humour willing out in the face of adversity. Watney remains relentlessly chipper throughout, aside from one or two instances where he punches things after setbacks occur, and he only displays outward signs of emotional fragility at the end of the film. This is a man who has been left for dead (on Mars, no less), has little to eat except for potatoes for hundreds of days on end, can only entertain himself with a poor collection of disco hits or a Happy Days box set (although we never get to see what he does with his surplus spuds) and is the subject of a rescue plan that requires him to head into space in a tin can covered with tarpaulin. Surely we should see him weep about his lot once or twice, rather than simply joke about it?

That said, I must admit I enjoyed being surprised by The Martian, and part of that surprise derives from the uplifting and comic tone, which is completely contrary to the human perservation story norm. I haven’t read Andy Weir’s source novel (adapted for the screen here by Drew Goddard) but I gather both book and screenplay are united in ditching the typically melodramatic links with home one would normally find in such tales, however far away the stranded protagonist may be; as such there’s no worried wife or cute little moppet waiting for dad to return, just a brief mention of a message Mark would like to be passed on to his parents, who we never actually see. This, coupled with the breezy, jokey nature, confounded my expectations. But I also feel like I can’t give The Martian an easy ride: too often the narrative is clumsily driven by people reading emails aloud, and the film’s inherent cheesiness may eventually test your patience, as it did mine. The final five minutes are particularly mawkish, and I also found myself cringing through many of the NASA-centric scenes; a subplot involving the China National Space The-Martian-Donald-GloverAdministration is unintentionally amusing (even though the Chinese authorities help with the rescue, Scott’s film descends into an unapologetic exercise in ‘Murican flag-waving by the end), while there’s far too much whooping and hollering and high-fiving at Mission Control throughout. I’m also ambivalent about seeing actors who have been excellent in bigger parts recently (such as Wiig, Chastain and Ejiofor) in smaller roles here. They’re all fine, though Wiig’s comic talents are curiously underplayed in what is essentially a fairly comic film, but in the past two or three years you could argue that each actor has developed beyond the point of playing second fiddle to Matt Damon. And I say that as a fan of Damon; he is a proper, old school movie star and he carries this film commendably, especially considering he’s all alone for most of it (Watney has no HAL 9000 or GERTY for company, sadly). All said it’s an enjoyable crowdpleaser, and one of Scott’s better films of recent years, but let’s not get carried away by all the hype. It isn’t a patch on earlier sci-fi masterpieces like this or this.

Directed by: Ridley Scott.
Written by: Drew Goddard. Based on The Martian by Andy Weir.
Starring: Matt Damon, Jessica Chastain, Jeff Daniels, Chiwetel Ejiofor, Michael Peña, Kristen Wiig, Kate Mara, Sean Bean, Sebastian Stan, Benedict Wong, Aksel Hennie, Donald Glover.
Cinematography: Dariusz Wolski.
Editing: Pietro Scalia.
Music: Harry Gregson-Williams, Various.
Certificate: 12A.
Running Time: 141 minutes.
Year: 2015.

Comments 18

    • Stu October 6, 2015

      Hey Dan, thanks very much. High praise indeed for this one; I can’t say I agree with you about it being one of the best movies of the year though, even though I enjoyed the film. It’s certainly one of the better blockbusters I’ve seen though.

  1. Mark Walker October 9, 2015

    This is the second review I’ve read today that doesn’t entirely praise this film. I was wondering if it could be possibly be as good as everyone seemed to be saying. Glad to hear your take on it bud.

  2. Three Rows Back October 11, 2015

    Not many sci-fi films can compete with Alien or Blade Runner I guess, but in terms of what we can expect from latter career Scott this is as good as we could have hoped for. I really enjoyed the film I gotta say and Damon once again proves why he’s such an old school movie star.

    • Stu October 12, 2015

      Yeah I’d go along with that, although I did actually enjoy The Counsellor, despite the terrible reviews. I didn’t think it was that bad. I didn’t actually hate Prometheus all that much either, but that’s just faint praise!

  3. Keith October 12, 2015

    Nice review. Mine just went up and you and I share many of the exact same reactions.I don’t fully go along with the intense hype even though I had quite a bit of fun with it.

  4. Todd Benefiel October 14, 2015

    I THOUGHT it was going to be a freebie, until I was told my pass wasn’t good for this screening. So, I forked over ten bucks and saw it anyway. And I’m going to try to write a review this week, but right now, in a nutshell: I felt the same way about it that you did. I loved the first half of the film, and Matt Damon and his character, but later, when things strayed too far from Mars, I began to lose interest. And the ‘light touch’ you mentioned really bugged me…but I’ll save more on that for my review.

    • Stu October 15, 2015

      Ah, so it’s one of those free ticket deals where the small print reads “only usable on Tuesdays between 2 and 7 am on Jennifer Lopez films”? I’ll look out for your review but sounds like you were a little disappointed.

  5. ckckred October 15, 2015

    Nice review man. Honestly, I’ve pretty much given up on Ridley Scott seeing how his recent movies have just been so bad. I haven’t been bought by The Martian’s hype, even after the surprisingly very positive reviews, though I’ll probably end up checking it out when it goes to VOD.

    • Stu October 15, 2015

      Cheers! There’s definitely something about hype that’s completely off-putting. Few films live up to it, and I don’t think this one does, but I did enjoy it. When I saw the trailer a few months back I thought it looked terrible, but was pleasantly surprised. Talk of Oscar nominations seems over the top to me though.

Leave a Reply to Three Rows Back Cancel reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s