0402 | Comet


Comet is the debut feature by the versatile Sam Esmail, a man who is enjoying considerable success at present as the creator, executive producer and head writer of the TV series Mr. Robot. This 2015 film, which he wrote as well as directed, may one day be viewed as an early career curio, given that it features a strong-but-forced visual style that could be developed into something special over the coming years: it’s a romantic drama that charts the six-year on-off relationship between cynical pessimist Dell (Justin Long) and occasionally-exasperated Kimberley (Emmy Rossum), with barely any screen time given to any other characters. Structurally it draws heavily from Marc Webb’s (500) Days Of Summer, opting for a non-linear path through the relationship from start to finish that means we’re aware pretty early on that they break-up at least once, although you could also describe Comet as a condensed version of Linklater’s Before trilogy (an homage, even, given that one passage takes place in a Paris hotel room). Several key moments from the six years are presented as vignettes, with some smart cross-cutting along the way by editor Franklin Peterson, allowing the viewer to form an overall impression of the couple’s love affair; to be honest they don’t actually seem all that compatible they meet and apparently live in LA but he’s drawn to New York, she wants to live in the present but he’s always looking to the future, and so on but despite the rows and the partings the ol’ flame of love refuses to go out etc. etc. and indeed etc.

I’m reminded of Linklater for another reason: this is an extremely talky indie, and perhaps one that is less clever than it thinks it is. There’s a depressing predictability about the casting of a vaguely-nerdy (but actually good looking man) playing opposite a woman who dresses and looks like (but thankfully does not act like) the archetypal Manic Pixie Dream Girl. As a kind of preemptive strike against the indifferent shrugs of everyone who is sick of watching relationship dramas about identikit millennials, Esmail tries to put a spin on things, supposing that the vignettes are taking place in a parallel, alternate universe. Unfortunately this comes across as an underdeveloped gimmick, and never more so than during the scenes in which we see twin suns in the background, which dutifully rise during the rooftop will-they, won’t-they finale. Still, arresting imagery like this is at least vaguely in keeping with the general theme of the couple’s fate being writ large in the stars; they meet-cute at an open air comet viewing event and the motif is continued via the dialogue and in the way cinematographer Eric Koretz occasionally emphasises the vastness of the sky. There’s a distinct colour palette too, with a range of indigos, pinks and violets used throughout, but sadly a lot of the time it feels like window dressing, and it can’t disguise the fact that watching Kimberley and Dell talk about the state of their relationship becomes boring all too quickly.

Directed by: Sam Esmail.
Written by: Sam Esmail.
Starring: Emmy Rossum, Justin Long.
Cinematography: Eric Koretz.
Editing: Franklin Peterson.
Daniel Hart.
Running Time:
89 minutes.

Comments 11

    • Stu November 13, 2015

      Nor for me! I think there’s some effort being made and plenty of creativity with the way the shots are framed and the editing and so on, but the screenplay (well, the dialogue side of it anyway) just didn’t do much for me at all.

  1. Mark Walker November 13, 2015

    I stumbled across this a while ago and didn’t think I’d be interested but I had no idea it was Mr. Robot’s Sam Esmail that put it together. You’re review has me cautious but I’ll still it out since Esmail is involved – I really like Mr. robot.

    • Stu November 13, 2015

      Yeah I’ve only watched a little bit of it but I’m getting into it! For some reason I’m imagining him as a new JJ Abrams or Joss Whedon type who will go on to bigger and better things, and this film will be interesting if that does happen, but otherwise it’s one of those dime-a-dozen indie romantic dramas, albeit with a few nice bells and whistles.

  2. Tom November 14, 2015

    I was completely underwhelmed by the whole “let’s set this in a parallel universe” idea; that was the cheesiest of the cheesy in a pretty cheesy movie. But I actually thought, despite how unlikable Justin Long was here, the acting went a long way in covering up some of the story’s ‘blegh’ construction. (Sorry I can’t think of the word. ‘Blegh’ just seems fitting lol!) I hadn’t heard of Emmy Rossum before this but I want to check out more stuff she’s in now. I really latched on to her character despite the cliches.

    • Stu November 16, 2015

      Yeah, me too! It didn’t really develop that idea at all, which is why I thought it was just window dressing that didn’t really mask the script’s shortcomings. I thought the two leads were both OK here, I’d certainly watch them in stuff again. I gather Long is fairly well known in the US but this is the first time I’d seen him in anything.

      • Tom November 16, 2015

        Oooh if that’s the case, you should try and get your hands on the most recent Kevin Smith movie, Tusk. It stars him in the most ridiculous body horror film I personally have ever seen. You might get a kick out of it.

        • Stu November 17, 2015

          Cheers, I will do. I’ve kind of given up on Smith but I was a huge fan early on, so I ough to check it out. It sounded weird!

        • Tom November 17, 2015

          Oh it’s totally bonkers. And I hated it personally, but it’s got another performance from Justin Long, so on that basis it fulfills a certain quota. lol. I’ll leave u to decide what to think of it.

  3. Todd Benefiel November 25, 2015

    Wait, twin suns? Did this take place on Tatooine? Yet ANOTHER movie you’ve seen that I’ve never heard of…but I enjoyed the review. Though I don’t think I’ll bother with the movie; I’ve got too many of your recommended ones to deal with first.

    • Stu November 25, 2015

      Thanks very much Todd. I can’t really push the hard sell on this one; I didn’t hate it, but I’m not a big fan. I also thought the same when I saw the twin suns appear. Maybe that was an homage.

Get in touch...

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s