The last film of Michael Mann’s to get bad reviews prior to Blackhat, 2006’s Miami Vice, has been the subject of a critical reappraisal in recent years. Some have suggested that Vice was unfairly written-off at the time of release, and while I couldn’t say whether I agree or not, having only watched it the once, I do wonder whether a similar reviewing awaits this 2015 box office flop in the future. I’m not suggesting for one minute that either Blackhat or Miami Vice is up there with Mann’s best work (let’s say Thief, Heat and The Insider, for argument’s sake) but I do think the reviews that labelled Blackhat slow-paced and boring were somewhat wide of the mark, and far too dismissive of its obvious qualities. In fact I’ve seen a couple of well-reasoned arguments made by respected critics and writers who have included Blackhat in a list of their favourite films of 2015, and while I don’t think I’ll be going that far myself I can certainly see why it has its champions.


Thor marks his emails from Captain America as ‘read’

Mann’s worst received film to date, it stars Chris Hemsworth as a former ‘black hat’ computer hacker (i.e. someone who uses their abilities for malicious purposes) taken out of jail to help on a joint FBI / Chinese government mission; his job is to track down a clever, ruthless cyber-opponent, and a pan-Asian game of cat and mouse ensues. Essentially what we have here is an old-school thriller with some ultra-modern window dressing. The plot feels like it has been kicking around for decades, bringing uneasy bedfellows from the east and west together in order to take down a common foe; where once we might have seen America and Russia teaming up today we have the US pooling its resources with China. The tech stuff adds a modern gloss, but even that’s filmed in a resolutely old-fashioned style, with lines of green code stacking up on small monitors and data shown passing through digitally-rendered cables and circuit boards. The action sequences – typically for Mann – are slow by today’s standards, but they’re as loud and as powerfully-rendered as ever. When the gunfire subsides the close combat also seems defiantly sluggish in an age where Bond, Hunt and Bourne leap from roof to roof and trade blows with their enemies at a fast and furious pace. Blackhat‘s hand-to-hand fighting is violent, though, and it’s as brutally swift as it is realistic, save for one scene in which Hemsworth’s Nick Hathaway beats up three turn-taking henchmen in a restaurant, which could have been lifted straight from a late ’80s Steven Seagal movie.

Some of Mann’s slickly-delivered tropes – the fascination with skyscrapers at night, the shots of choppers and sleek private jets leaving or arriving in cities – have gradually become old hat, too, but they’re still as aesthetically-pleasing as they ever were. Perhaps I was in the right mood, but I enjoyed all of this, and I feel like it’s still a pleasure to see this auteur’s signature moves and style, even if the character types and plot points are becoming a little wearisome. Hathaway is your typical Mann protagonist: a strong, suave silent type who happens to be an expert in his field, he’s on the trail of a dangerous man who is on the other side of the law, though they share some common traits. Hemsworth is a good fit for such a part even if it is a stretch to accept the muscular, glowing leading man as a Foucault-reading hacker. (The running, fighting and shooting? No problem at all.) Opposite him Tang Wei, who starred in Ang Lee’s Lust, Caution, doesn’t really have a great deal to do, which is a shame. Her character is supposedly a high-ranking engineer, but ends up deferring to Hathaway, dutifully following his orders when he says it’s for the best if she leaves and returning to his arms like rather pathetically when the film requires a dash of romantic action. Perhaps slightly more interesting in terms of the supporting characters is Viola Davis’ cold, sarcastic FBI agent, but sadly even she becomes just another person who is in thrall of Hemsworth’s Hathaway, following him from location to location as he gradually becomes the group’s de facto leader.

Three big action set-pieces arrive in the second half of the film, all gripping. Perhaps that’s indicative of Blackhat‘s biggest problem: there’s nothing quite as thrilling as these during the first half, and even Mann struggles to make the scenes in which someone types or reads code on a screen even remotely interesting; there are far too many of these as Hathaway and co latch onto their opponent’s trail. So yes, Blackhat is a little disjointed: I much preferred the second half to the first, but I’d still take a Michael Mann action thriller over the numerous efforts churned out by hack directors each year, and there’s enough here for fans to get their teeth into. Not his best, by any means, but certainly not the stinker it was made out to be.

Directed by: Michael Mann.
Written by: Morgan Davies Foehl, Michael Mann.
Starring: Chris Hemsworth, Tang Wei, Viola Davis, Holt McCallany, Wang Leehom.
Cinematography: Stuart Dryburgh.
Editing: Joe Walker, Stephen E. Rivkin, Jeremiah O’Driscoll, Mako Kamitsuna.
 Atticus Ross, Harry Gregson-Williams.
Running Time:
133 minutes.

9 Responses to “0437 | Blackhat”

  1. ckckred

    Nice review Stu. Michael Mann has made some of the best thrillers over the past several decades but it seems to be ages since he made a good film.

    • Stu

      Thanks very much Charles. I think the last four or so have been OK…not up there with his best, but I’ve enjoyed each one for various reasons!

  2. Tom

    Very refreshing to read a review that doesn’t pummel this movie into the ground. (Even though I will openly admit I contributed to that party.) When I first saw it I was excited to see Hemsworth operating in a different capacity. I noticed a lot of people really took issue with him being miscast, and while I can’t really disagree I didn’t let it affect me so much. What I took more of an issue with was the pacing and the supremely jargonistic script that left me feeling out of the loop and more or less indifferent to how everything would conclude. Coming in with very little exposure to Michael Mann’s filmography helped me take it down a peg, I guess. I think I’ll need to go back and revisit this thing again to see if it’s as bad as I remember it. Chances are, it probably won’t be.

    • Stu

      Thanks Tom. I guess it can be down to timing in terms of when you watch something. I was expecting the worst because of all the negative reviews I’d seen (though I’d read some positive ones too) so it was a pleasant surprise to find something “not bad”. If I’d seen it at the cinema in the middle of awards season I might have felt a little differently. I did have a little trouble with Hemsworth as a superbrain hacker but gradually that gets left behind for physical action during the film so I didn’t feel he was too out of place.

      • Tom

        Timing probably is a huge phactre here. Give it a few months when people have forgotten it a bit more, and it’ll be rediscovered again and possibly embrace it for what it is. Certainly now rethinking its position on a certain, uh, undignified list I’m putting together

        • Stu

          Phactre! Like it. So I guess we can expect a ‘worst of the year’ on your blog then?!

        • Tom

          As part of my end-of-year post, I try to sneak in a crop of films I wasn’t very impressed with, yes. Keep an eye peeled. 😉

  3. Three Rows Back

    Well said. My review from earlier this year backs this up. I thought it was unfairly maligned and, despite some creaky nonsense, it has Mann’s stamp all over it.

    • Stu

      Definitely; I went into it half-expecting to see one of the worst films of the year, although I’d seen a couple of passionate defences too that suggested it was one of the best. I think for me it lies somewhere in the middle of those opposites, but that was a pleasant surprise in itself. In fact I’d err more on the side of saying ‘quite good’ if I was feeling dangerous.


Get in touch...

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s